Showing posts with label 2016 Iowa Caucus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2016 Iowa Caucus. Show all posts

Friday, February 5, 2016

The Democrats Had a Bad Night in Iowa, Might Have One Again in November

I'm getting sick of it. I'm getting sick of my fellow Democrats. I'm getting sick of my fellow Democrats celebrating the defeat of Donald Trump in Iowa. For real. You're celebrating what was a terrible night, if what you want is a Democratic President. Nothing that happened in Iowa was a positive for the party's chances of winning the White House.

Look, I know you hate Donald Trump. He's run a white-nationalist, or racist, campaign for the Presidency, and riled up hillbillies and swamp people you didn't want to believe exist. I understand. He also would have been the easiest general election opponent to defeat, most likely. He has a track record of saying crazy things, shady business dealings, and bad personal morals. He would helped Democrats win over independents, and win back down-ballot races. Had he won Iowa, he would have rolled New Hampshire easily, and possibly walked to the nomination of the Republican Party in 2016. Even if he hadn't, a few more months of peak-Trump would have forced even the "establishment" Republicans to say more and more crazy, Trump-esque things. In short, him winning helps hurt the Republican Party's chances of victory in November. If you are a Democrat, you want that.

Then there's what his defeat meant within the GOP's race more directly. Ted Cruz "out-Iowa'ed" him, and may or may not have a pathway forward from there (Iowa usually gets Republican primaries wrong). The problem is that Marco Rubio finished third, and quite close to Trump at that. Republican political operatives all over DC awoke from their decade or so slumber, and realized that they had a pathway for an "establishment" candidate to take the nomination. They are now frantically trying to kill off the other "establishment" candidates like Bush, Kasich, and Christie, and leave Rubio to fight the dual-crazies of Cruz and Trump. Because Cruz won, Trump won't be able to clear him out quickly, leaving Rubio with an actual pathway to victory now. Is Marco Rubio that scary? Electorally I don't think he's stronger than Romney was in 2012, but we're not running President Obama against their nominee either. As an actual President, someone as scripted and stupid as Rubio is absolutely horrifying. He will literally do the bidding of his corporate masters who fund him.

I won't go too far into depth about the Democratic race, other than to say that nothing good happened on Monday. If nothing else, the Bernie crowd feels he was cheated. If either candidate's people walk away feeling cheated at the end of the process, it will make it that much harder to win in November. Beyond that, Bernie raised another $3 million and looks like a serious candidate now, leading to what is likely to be another drawn out, brutal battle for the nomination. I think we all know that Hillary Clinton won't be getting out of the race any time soon. We're now going to have a left-wing brawl over whether we should have more access to health insurance or Medicare for all. I'm not sure I see that as helping us.

Look, I get it- you get to call Donald Trump a "loser." Continuing to focus on Trump's follies is not helping us win an election though. If we don't win the election, who's the loser then?

I'm a Fan of the Iowa Caucus

I get it- you think Iowa's the worst. It's too rural, too white, too old, the people have nothing to do- you're way over-generalizing, but you're entitled to your opinion. Maybe you hate caucuses, because you know, there's more process than a mindless push of a button, which is also fine. You're just wrong.

I love that the Presidential election process starts out in a place where television buys are cheap, and you can get a crowd out to watch any Presidential candidate on any day of the week. The people are engaged, reasonable, and yet passionate. You can't do this on the East or West Coast, the public just wouldn't engage all the candidates like this. You shouldn't do it in a larger state either, the retail aspect will be gone. If you had a national primary day, or rotated the "first in the nation" status, the nominations of the two parties would simply be put up for sale to the highest bidder, and all that would matter is fundraising numbers, as though they don't now.

Maybe you wouldn't like to visit Iowa- that's your loss. It's a great place, and I enjoy visiting. If you don't like it, don't run for President, no one is making you. Just cool it with your, "why Iowa?" questions every four years. You'll never quite understand.

To close, here's the Iowa Democratic results, by county. I'm looking forward to Iowa 2024.

Tuesday, February 2, 2016

Thoughts on Iowa

It's over. The Iowa Caucus is over. The results are in, we know who won, and we know who won. The first votes were cast in the race to be the 45th President of the United States. The caucus-goers are the first real signs we have of who has the momentum in this race.

First off, for lack of any other way to put it, the Democratic race was a tie. Hillary Clinton currently has 699 delegate-equivalencies to the state convention, while Bernie Sanders has 695. Given that there are eight Martin O'Malley delegates won last night, it is fair to say that no one will know who won Iowa until those folks select which side they want to go to. I do know that people are disputing how we should count this race, but there's not many ways to slice a race this close.

The Republican race was shocking. Donald Trump turned out the second most caucus-goers in Republican history. He lost. I would not have predicted that. Ted Cruz had an incredible organization, and shocked even me. Marco Rubio also shocked me, not by finishing third, but by finishing so close to Trump.

Here's my winners from last night:

  1. Bernie Sanders- No, he didn't really win. He also isn't Howard Dean. While there was a quiet thought that this man might be a flop once real voting happened, he showed us that his campaign is real. His speech felt like the "victory" speech on the Democratic side, and he showed that he can turn out the kids, the newcomers to the process, and the more progressive base. He has a big lead in New Hampshire, and it's fair to say that last night should not change that. While he didn't get the decisive victory that would change the race over night, his position is no worse than it was.
  2. Hillary Clinton- If the results hold, she will be the first Clinton to win Iowa. She will also be the first woman to ever win Iowa. She avoided a repeat of 2008, which was really the bar to clear. She is in a good position to win the nomination, and last night didn't change that.
  3. Ted Cruz- I mean, he won the Iowa Caucus. He got the most votes in the history of the event too. His base of Evangelicals and arch-conservatives won the night. 
  4. Marco Rubio- He's one step closer to being the "establishment" Republican. He's going to take some serious fire in New Hampshire now, but I'd rather be in his position than anyone else's.
I was almost tempted to put Donald Trump in here for handling the loss with modesty, but I'll pass for now. The night is a loss for Jeb Bush, John Kasich, Rand Paul, and Christ Christie. All of them did considerably more poor than I thought. 

On to New Hampshire!

Monday, February 1, 2016

Final Prediction- Democratic Iowa Caucus

The last two Iowa Democratic winners
It's time for my final prediction for tonight's Iowa Democratic Caucus:

  1. Hillary Clinton 50%
  2. Bernie Sanders 48%
  3. Martin O'Malley 2%

Final Predictions- Iowa Republican Caucus

Alright, the Iowa Caucus is underway. It's time for final predictions. Here's my final Iowa prediction:

  1. Donald Trump 28%
  2. Ted Cruz 27%
  3. Marco Rubio 15%
  4. Rand Paul 11%
  5. Ben Carson 9%
  6. Jeb Bush 5%
  7. Carly Fiorina 2%
  8. John Kasich 2%
  9. Chris Christie 1%

"The Movement" and History

In a little while, the Iowa Caucuses will happen, and the very first "votes" will be cast in the race to become the 45th President of the United States. It is a historic moment, and it is a moment that people around the globe will watch closely.

Bernie Sanders is trying to shock the political world. If he wins the Iowa Caucus, he will set himself up to sweep the Iowa and New Hampshire contests to start the process, and take his "political revolution" national. He started this process down by a 61-5% margin in the state, and now is within just a couple of points in most polls. Many find this pretty unbelievable, even unprecedented. It is unbelievable. It is not unprecedented.

Whether you call them "movements," anti-establishment, underdogs, or just "more liberal," candidates like Bernie Sanders have existed in the past. President Obama somewhat fit that mold in 2008, though history now shows us that he was much more "mainstream" and moderate than perhaps he was cast in 2008. Howard Dean was certainly this candidate in 2004, as was Bill Bradley in 2000. Go back further and you find Eugene McCarthy or George McGovern. In case you're noticing this, most of these candidates didn't win, besides President Obama. In other words, this isn't easy to do.

Furthermore standing in Bernie's way is the current condition- Democrats hold the White House. It's not really a "change" election, let alone a revolution, to Democrats who will vote in this process. Bernie has made his differences with the President, particularly on banking and health care, front and center in this race. Is it doable? I'd suggest it's pretty hard to be the "change" guy against the President with 90% approval in the caucus.

Iowa does have a way of bringing surprises out, and that could happen tonight. It's not as likely as a Clinton victory though. If Sanders wins tonight, it's pretty much a huge upset. History tells us that tonight, if Sanders does well, that is a very big deal.

The Kids Keep Getting Better at this Stuff

When I was working the Iowa Caucus in 2007 and 2008, we thought we were pretty awesome at innovation. Smart phones were relatively new, votebuilder was a new thing, Twitter was brand new, it was the first "Facebook election," and campaigns were using text messaging to reach their audience. It's only been one Presidency, eight years, and it seems like a lot less. We were stone age compared to this election though.

Last night I was out with my cousin when my phone gave me an "alert" from Facebook: Hillary Clinton was live from Lincoln High School in Des Moines, IA. Of course, being intrigued I clicked it, and watched her rally live-streamed. In that live-stream, I could communicate in real time with others watching the speech. The campaign could also communicate to me. We thought Podcasts and blogs were a big deal in 2008.

I believe that eight years from now, elections will probably be largely contested over the internet. We're simply moving into a more technological nation and world, and it only makes sense that our politics would follow that direction. I'm kind of amazed at how fast the advances are happening, and really how much has changed in eight years. I can only imagine what it will look like eight years from now.

Happy Iowa Caucus Day- Fleetwood Mac- "Don't Stop"

Sunday, January 31, 2016

Hillary's Iowa Lead, and the Final Outcome

Now that the final Iowa Poll is out from the Des Moines Register, I think it is fair to say that Hillary has a narrow lead in the race for President. The previous Iowa Poll had Hillary up 42-40%, a narrow lead with a month to go that made me believe that Bernie Sanders was going to simply blow by her and win Iowa, relatively close. That a few weeks later, we're looking at a 45-42% Hillary lead means that never managed to happen. My prediction that Bernie would win isn't necessarily obsolete, but it's less likely. The Iowa Poll has a great record of nailing the final results in the caucus, and they continue to show Hillary leading, which at least should give pause to those who see a 2008 repeat.

The bottom line out of that poll is that the race stabilized, her fall stopped, and this race is in the hands of a hand full of caucus-goers. Hillary Clinton is now at 45%, and leading, but that is not 50%, and that does not show me how it will equate out into caucus delegates. On the one hand, she probably leads, even after second choicers decide. On the other hand, 10% are still undecided, and the race is well within range for them to decide the election.

Let's look at several factors that are still out there on this race:

  • O'Malley's 3% in the poll represents a number so low that he's unlikely to win many delegates. In every caucus site in the state, you have to reach a 15% minimum to win delegates and remain viable. When you don't reach that point, you have to make a second choice. In the only polling on this that I have seen, Bernie leads Hillary by a 2:1 margin. If that is the final outcome, you can add 2% to Bernie and 1% to Hillary, which would make the race 46-44%. In other words, it's a significant group, in a close race, however this alone probably won't change the caucus. Bernie would still need more than that to win. Bottom line for Martin O'Malley though is that I'd be surprised if his 3% in the poll brings him 3% of the delegates won.
  • If we assume that about one in ten Democrats are undecided, as this poll shows, this is where the race is likely to be decided. Again though, if Hillary in fact does have a 2-3% lead going into this vote, Bernie will have to win this group significantly. A 60-40% victory amongst the undecideds may get him a victory, but even at that level it's no lock. Bernie's likely going to need a huge number amongst these people, people who haven't been won over by anyone yet. I do assume he will at least win these people though, as I am not sure what new information about Hillary Clinton is going to change someone's mind at this point.
  • So what about the "Benedict Arnold" vote, or the people who will change their mind? Amongst Hillary's supporters, 83% have made up their mind. Amongst Bernie's supporters, 69% won't change. In other words, this isn't likely to be Bernie's pathway to victory.
  • Hillary leads amongst experienced caucus-goers, while Bernie leads amongst people who say they will "probably" go. The first time caucus-goers number is at 30%. Hillary leads amongst older voters, Bernie amongst younger voters. In short, if Bernie's going to win, he's going to need to have a great turnout game. He's going to have to do that with a tougher group of caucus-goers to turnout, and a rather average number of "new caucus-goers" coming out right now.
  • In case you think there is an intensity gap in Iowa? Both have over 80% approval, she has a narrow lead on the question of "enthusiasm" for one of them being nominee.
  • Yes, this race is within the margin of error. Bernie could actually be ahead. When several polls in a row show a narrow lead for a candidate though, I tend to believe it. It's worth entertaining that he might be ahead, but I'm fairly confident in the consistency here, and that it's the Iowa poll.
All of that leads to one conclusion- it's really, really close, but Hillary is likely to win. If Bernie is going to win, he will do so by driving turnout north of 200,000, and winning by a much larger margin in Johnson, Story, and Polk Counties. Hillary can put the race away by holding her own in the east and beating him much worse in Western Iowa than is expected. I'm watching counties like Black Hawk (Waterloo), Dubuque, Scott (Davenport), and Linn (Cedar Rapids), all quite large, and all being counties where I could see either of them doing very well. 

The bottom line? Hillary managed to stabilize the race in Iowa over the last month, and probably leads a very narrow race. Bernie can still win Iowa, but it's going to be considerably harder than it looked a few weeks ago.

Friday, January 29, 2016

My Iowa Republican Forecast

Donald Trump is filling every venue he uses in Iowa. He's drawing thousands of people to his events. He's clearly the candidate with the energy and enthusiasm in the Republican field in Iowa at this point. Ted Cruz is focusing on more "traditional" Evangelical audiences, and Marco Rubio and others are simply finding some spots for them to compete and try to surprise.

We have seen this before though on both sides. Huge crowds don't necessarily mean a better caucus performance, as sometimes it can be hard to turn out those people on caucus night. The reality is that those people all have to show up Monday night, on time, and go through the process. The Republican process is less quirky than the Democratic one, but it still requires organization to turn people out. Ultimately, the strength of Team Trump on the ground will decide this race.

I don't think Ted Cruz is in good shape. That he's turning to his original base in the closing days tells me he doesn't have momentum anymore. I also don't really think anyone else, including Marco Rubio, is in great shape to catch him. Even though Mike Huckabee and Rick Santorum has won the last two caucuses, neither seems poised to take off next Monday and challenge again, and both could be done. Rand Paul could be in a position to surprise us Monday, as he has a pretty decent organization there, but he never really caught fire either. No one else seems like they are even really relevant.

I'm going to say Trump is the guy to beat Monday. All he has to do is turn out a large chunk of his crowds, and he should win Iowa. Cruz certainly does have a shot to win, but he also has a shot to disappoint and fall on his face. Paul and Rubio are the other two I'm watching closely, with Bush, Huckabee, and Santorum all likely to show up with some degree of support. Huckabee and Santorum's success or lack thereof will either kill or boost Cruz, while any caucus goers for Bush do a little more to kill off Rubio. A Trump win may put the nomination within his reach, given his New Hampshire lead. A Cruz win means he has a real shot to win the nomination. Rubio needs a strong third to boost him to a clear second or better in New Hampshire. Paul could revive his efforts with a third place finish. The stakes are high, but knowing that Trump did hire some solid Iowa operatives to do his caucus effort, I'd bet on his chances on Monday.

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

Why I Think Bernie Will Win Iowa, Why It's No Lock, and Why It Might Not Matter

Iowa Caucus going Democrats just aren't enamored with Hillary Clinton. She may or may not win them in the end, this time, but eight years ago they sank her candidacy with a third place finish. It appeared that she was safely on her way to victory this time, but now that's not so. The Des Moines Register's last poll showed her lead all the way down to 2%, putting her in danger of losing again. This contest continues to be a problem for her.

Hillary Clinton's lead is down to 42-40% in the DMR Poll, the one poll I'd typically bet on in Iowa. The reason it got closer was a drop in support for Clinton, not a rise in support for Bernie. Even so, Bernie seems to have the momentum out there, not Hillary. If this seems to be 2008 all over again to you, it might be. That's also no lock. This movement in the race means one of two things will happen: Either momentum will carry Bernie to victory or voters who went undecided will decide he's not a viable choice to lead the party forward.

I've worked in Iowa twice, including on a caucus, and have a few theories about the state of the race with six days left. Here are my thoughts:

I think Bernie Sanders will win Iowa
My guess is that momentum leaning his way will carry Bernie Sanders to a victory. The race is very close, and while much has been made that his campaign is not Obama's, he's still running a very solid Iowa operation. Martin O'Malley is unlikely to be viable in much of the state, and so his supporters will get a second choice on caucus night. In the only polling on that subject that i've seen, Bernie leads big. If the race remains very close, that might just decide the caucus. If the caucus is just made up of people who caucused before, Bernie is in trouble, but the "enthusiasm gap" leans his way, and Hillary is scrambling to close it. Demographics and ideology also lean his way- the state is largely white, and the caucus-goers are more liberal than the population at-large. Bernie is also polling very strong in delegate-rich Eastern Iowa, much like President Obama did.

All of this ads up to my guess right now- Bernie will win, close, in Iowa. He won't crush her, I don't think, and it may not be that he ends up actually winning Iowa once they get to state convention, but for now he'll be up.

It's Not a Lock Though
Hillary isn't behaving like she's dead in Iowa. Lena Dunham, Demi Lovato, and Bill Clinton aren't surrogates you send into a state you're toast in. Sure, it's better for her if she wins there, so of course she should try, but if she were out of it, you'd see her sending resources elsewhere.

Here's the alternative scenario to Bernie's momentum carrying him to victory in Iowa- he never really had a chance. The race got close because Clinton supporters in Iowa moved back to undecided. They haven't been with Bernie yet. Perhaps him getting close, and therefore being viewed more seriously, will convince Iowans that he's not worth the chance. Perhaps they will come home to her in the closing weeks, and stick with the "safe" pick. It would be a break from the 2004 and 2008 contests, where momentum carried the day, but it wouldn't be outlandish to think it could happen.

Winning Iowa Might Not Matter
In 2004, a victory in Iowa shot John Kerry from the middle of the pack nationally to the nomination. in 2008, President Obama's Iowa victory was the key in spring-boarding him to the nomination. In 2016, Bernie Sanders may not be in the same position. President Obama's victory in Iowa was such a big deal in no small part because it defied all history on demographic politics to see an African-American Presidential candidate win in such a white state. For many reasons that have been discussed, Bernie winning in such a white state is not as big of a deal. Iowa only will have a dramatic impact on the race if Hillary wins it- because it will probably end the nomination fight, for all intents and purposes.

Bernie Sanders ultimately needs to follow a similar path to John Kerry's 2004 path, sweeping Iowa and New Hampshire to have any kind of shot at the victory. Even then, Clinton holds a substantial lead in national polling, and a particularly strong lead amongst African-American voters who will be key in South Carolina and on Super Tuesday. Even as Bernie's "surge" has been ongoing over this past month, it hasn't lead him to better numbers amongst this key demographic yet. If he's losing amongst African-Americans, Latinos, and other key groups within the party, he's not going to be the nominee without narrowing the margins. That's particularly key when you think about Nevada, South Carolina, and the "SEC States" that will vote on Super Tuesday.

Finally, there is the ace-in-the-hole of all of this- I think President Obama wants Hillary Clinton to be the nominee. If Hillary can simply hold on in either Nevada, South Carolina, or both, I think it's entirely possible that he will endorse her. That would be a substantial blow to Bernie's chances of winning the nomination.

Bernie has to win Iowa, and New Hampshire, to win the nomination. Even if he does that though, he still would be an underdog to win. I would predict a Sanders victory in Iowa, but I'd also argue that this isn't that crucial to the end result, ultimately.

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

Some Key Things to Watch in the Democratic Battle for Iowa

Des Moines is a really wonderful city. Here's the capitol.
The winner of the Democratic Caucus in Iowa might end up deciding the way the race for the Democratic nomination goes. We are under two weeks now from the February 1st caucus, and it's really close. If Hillary Clinton wins the Iowa Caucuses, she may roll to the nomination. If Bernie Sanders wins in Iowa, he may be able to sweep the first two, or maybe more states, and knock her off her feet. Polls suggest it's close though, so what should we watch for?

  1. Martin O'Malley's supporters and their second choice- Iowa Starting Line explains this much better than me, but on caucus night you don't always get to support your candidate of choice in the Democratic Party. If your candidate does not have 15% of that caucus site, they are declared non-viable, and you have to pick someone else (or no one at all). That is likely to happen to O'Malley in a lot of places. Polling is few and far between on this, though the one that does exist suggests Sanders benefits here. If it's truly a single digit contest, this will matter.
  2. Northeast Iowa- Eastern Iowa in general is the more liberal half, and Bernie Sanders should do rather well here. Northeast Iowa is a little different though. Dubuque and Waterloo are both Catholic-esque, blue-collar centers, with a viable labor presence and less ideological tilt. Barack Obama crushed Hillary Clinton in these areas last time, and there are pockets of Joe Biden loyalists up here. If Clinton is going to win, she needs to do well up here.
  3. Independents- The Iowa Caucus is unique to many voters around the country because you can declare your party that day. Independents can show up and choose a candidate. Conventional wisdom for a long time was that they would caucus in the Republican side, because it's more interesting. With the Democratic contest narrowing, and the GOP contest growing more and more conservative, that's in question now. Who will they back?
  4. Greater Des Moines- The Iowa Caucus "weights" counties by their size and Democratic performance. Polk County, home of Des Moines, is the runaway largest county in the state, and has some fairly progressive people in it. The counties around it are not as large, but they are significant and combined up with Polk, make up a very large minority of the delegates overall. If either candidate can win this region cleanly, they probably will win the caucus. Clinton is expected to win in Western Iowa, and Sanders should do well in Eastern Iowa. The center may break the tie.
  5. College Towns- Howard Dean made Iowa City, Ames, Des Moines, Cedar Falls, Waverly, Grinnell, and other college towns centerpieces of his strategy in 2004, and he failed. In 2008, President Obama did the same thing, and it paid off huge for him. In 2016, Bernie Sanders has a commanding lead amongst the younger generation, and will look to repeat President Obama's performance. A good college program can swing Johnson, Story, Black Hawk, Polk, Poweshiek, Bremer, Dubuque, and Linn counties, potentially, to name a few. This will be crucial to Sanders' chances.
These are just a few keys to the Iowa Caucus, but they are good storylines to watch. One other thing to watch? The Des Moines Register. Their endorsement will be a major feather to one of the candidate's caps. If they poll again before the caucus (they just did one that had Clinton up 2%), that will also be worth watching- they're almost never wrong. With the race this close, I hope they do one more, just to see if it's still moving.

Either way, it's close in Iowa. Hopefully this helps you watch better.