Showing posts with label The European Refugee Crisis of 2015. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The European Refugee Crisis of 2015. Show all posts

Monday, November 23, 2015

A Little Truth on the Refugee Screening Process

This is from the Arab American Institute. Check it out.

What 90 Year Old Bobby Kennedy Would Tell Us On Refugees

On November 20th, Robert F. Kennedy would have turned 90 years old. He was famously assassinated 47 years ago in June as a young man running for President of the United States. Rather than looking sadly at his death, I think America could use a little bit of the positivity of his life right now. We should remember what Kennedy, and our nation, stood for at that time.

Right now we have political leaders in this country that are calling for America to turn it's back on Syrian Refugees seeking shelter from a brutal civil war at home. They say the risk to our people is too great, despite the rigorous process refugees go through to get here, and it's nearly perfect historical record. They say we should be fearful of people who are fleeing fear- fear of ISIS, of a government that slaughters them, and yet other bad people who are fighting in a civil war that is void of many "good" guys. They say we should turn our back on them, and protect ourselves. The world is a bad place, a scary place, after all. The real solution is to bomb them in Syria, or go back in with ground troops, they say.

RFK's life had many contradictions, but the man that died in June of 1968 had become the moral voice of a generation. He had risen up to take on the Johnson Administration on Vietnam, becoming the voice of the millions who wanted the unjust war to end. He fought for the freedom and dignity of people around the world in need. Most importantly though, I look to the moral leader he had become on the dignity of people here, and Civil Rights. On the night of the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr., a night in which peoples' better instincts went by the wayside in many cities across our nation, Kennedy spoke in Indianapolis and called on peoples' better angels to prevail, despite the fear and despair they were feeling. He asked people to look beyond the fear of the moment, and look to the world they wanted to live in.

In the wake of the scary, terrible events of Paris, many of our political leaders are calling on us to live in fear. Fear the refugees, and reject their entry to our nation. I don't believe RFK would be agreeing with them. For a man who remained so hopeful, even after the brutal killing of his brother in the service to our nation, I don't think he'd tell us to reject a founding principle of our nation in the name of fear. I doubt he'd say let's "pause" the working refugee system because it *might* not be good enough, despite evidence that it is. RFK would not have lived in the fear that many of our leaders do today. Not everyone can be RFK all of the time, I do understand that. It would be nice if our leaders at least aspired to though.

Thursday, November 19, 2015

For My Conservative Friends

Several corrections for my conservative friends-

1. Despite what conservative media sites reporting, the President did not say he doesn't care if "America wins." You should watch his unedited statement. Like many things reported by Fox, or other conservative news sources, it's doctored.

2. No refugees have been arrested for aiding ISIS in the U.S. None. If a site is saying otherwise, that site is incorrect.

3. All refugees go through an in-depth vetting. It takes 12-18 months in most cases. There is no need for "more." We do an excellent job at that now. There have been no arrests on domestic terror charges by a refugee in the last 750,000 cases. The U.S. does a much better job than even most European nations at vetting refugees, and it's insulting actually that the fine people who work at this are being questioned by Congressional failures.

4. Christians commit plenty of acts of terror, as do all religious groups. I would point to the Charleston shootings this year, or the Oklahoma City Bombing. We don't try to keep out Christian refugees though, nor should we. This entire debate is idiotic. We don't do religious tests in America. We took in thousands of Muslim Bosnians in the 1990s and early 2000s, and that was the right thing to do. Let's not become a bunch of bigots now.

5. Please stop celebrating Vladimir Putin's "toughness." That's great that he says he'll kill ISIS. He's also actively supporting a dictator who is massacring his own people by the thousands. Being tough and stupid is not a virtue, it's a failing.

Wednesday, November 18, 2015

President Obama, Summing It Up Best

White House photo of the President and the French Foreign Minister
This pretty much nails it:
Obama also argued that he "cannot think of a more potent recruitment tool for ISIL than some of the rhetoric coming out of here in the course of this debate" than the idea of discriminating against Muslim refugees.
"ISIL seeks to exploit the idea that there's war between Islam and the West," Obama said. "And when you start seeing individuals in position of responsibility suggesting Christians are more worthy of protection than Muslims are in a war-torn land that feeds the ISIL narrative, it's counterproductive. And it needs to stop." 
Take notes from a pro, Marco Rubio and friends. 

No Republican Candidate is Qualified or Capable to be President

The Republican answer is always to talk tough. Even after the great failure that was the Iraq War, this hasn't changed. They want to talk tough with Iran, tough with North Korea, tough on Syria, tough on ISIS, and even tough on Cuba. They want sanctions, wars, bombings, and covert operations all over the place. The default answer is tough. It doesn't matter what the question is. It doesn't matter who they're talking about. They want to go down the same failed road. We've spent most of the last fifteen years trying to fight terrorists through war- it hasn't worked. That hasn't moved these people at all.

Jeb Bush and Ted Cruz are calling for a religious screening test, to only admit Christians fleeing Syria. Marco Rubio is calling for a "clash of civilizations," also known as a war against Islam. Mike Huckabee can't name any non-Muslim terrorists. Ben Carson wants to build a coalition to fight ISIS, but can't name any partners. Chris Christie would even ban "orphans under five" from coming here as refugees. Donald Trump would end the discussion of bringing in refugees.

These guys don't get basic facts right, and have some of the most half-baked plans to deal with Syria, ISIS, and the refugees that I've ever seen. Let's touch on a few facts-

  • Since we're talking coalitions and fight against ISIS, it's important to note that there is a coalition, which France is part of. This idea that there needs to be an Arab coalition is a fight over things already done. If this is about the Saudis getting involved, don't hold your breath. If this is about the Iranians, they are already there, on the side of Russia and the Syria Government, against ISIS and others. We are not on that side.
  • Even George W. Bush didn't want a "clash of civilizations." He carefully made sure to note we weren't fighting Islam. Marco Rubio would not be so careful. He'd like to re-hash the crusades.
  • The U.S. has taken 745,000 refugees since 9/11, and none of them have been arrested on domestic terrorism charges. We certainly could take children in with little fear of letting in "terrorists." The government does a great job at this.
  • For Jeb, he should look to recent history in regards to letting Muslims in. In the 1990s and into the early 2000s, the U.S. took thousands of Bosnians into the United States. Bosnians are Muslim, traditionally. There's no record of them being terrorists.
No one running for the Republican nomination is qualified or capable of running this country. None of them would make a good President. None of them is really capable of doing a good job. Hopefully none of them win.

Tuesday, November 17, 2015

Refugees Should Not Scare You

I understand that people are afraid. ISIS is a scary group. Terrorism is scary in general. We all remember 9/11. We've all seen these guys behead people. I understand the reaction of fear, and I don't blame people for it.

None of that fear is a good reason to abandon our values though. We have always been there to support those distressed people in the world who need asylum. Just around two decades ago, we took thousands of Bosnians in during the civil war in the former Yugoslavia. It is who we are. It is who we should be. To not be that nation is to let the terrorists win.

It's also quite safe for us to live up to our values:
Refugees apply for resettlement at American embassies or through the United Nations. If they pass that first hurdle, they are screened by outposts of the Department of State all over the world. They undergo investigations of their biography and identity; FBI biometric checks of their fingerprints and photographs; in-person interviews by Department of Homeland Security officers; medical screenings as well as investigations by the National Counter-terrorism Centre and by American and international intelligence agencies. The process may take as long as three years, sometimes longer. No other person entering America is subjected to such a level of scrutiny.
Refugee resettlement is the least likely route for potential terrorists, says Kathleen Newland at the Migration Policy Institute, a think-tank. Of the 745,000 refugees resettled since September 11th, only two Iraqis in Kentucky have been arrested on terrorist charges, for aiding al-Qaeda in Iraq.
Asylum-seekers have to navigate through a similar bureaucratic tangle. The decision to grant asylum is made by a Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) officer. If that officer finds that the applicant did not make his case convincingly, he receives a “Notice of Intent to Deny” (NOID) as long as his immigration status as, say, a tourist or student is still valid. He is then allowed to submit further evidence to bolster his case, though such decisions are rarely reversed. If the applicant’s immigration status is no longer valid, he is placed in deportation proceedings before an immigration court. The applicant then has a second chance to make his case in court while a government lawyer argues that he should be deported. In March this year, USCIS had 82,175 asylum cases pending. Last year each immigration judge handled, on average, 1,500 cases a year, double or even triple the caseload of other judges.
In other words, there's nothing to be afraid of. Let's be America, not let our fear make us give in to ISIS. 

Irresponsible Marco Wants to Fight an Entire Religion, Apparently

Marco Rubio makes me sick sometimes. Calling for a war with Islam is one of them:
Marco Rubio appeared on This Week yesterday morning, where he took umbrage at Hillary Clinton’s statement that the United States is “at war with jihadists” but not “at war with Islam.” Rubio declared himself baffled by Clinton’s carefully parsed distinctions. “I don't understand it,” said Rubio. “That would be like saying we weren't at war with the Nazis, because we were afraid to offend some Germans who may have been members of the Nazi Party, but weren't violent themselves.” If we tease out Rubio’s metaphor, the Muslim faith as a whole is equivalent to Nazism, and violent jihadi terrorists are the equivalent of the Nazi leadership. Rubio has a knack for grasping the midpoint of Republican Party doctrine at any given moment, and his comments reflect the party’s renewed conviction that the war against terrorists must be defined in the broadest possible terms.
The Obama administration, like the Bush administration before it, believes in defining the conflict in the most narrow terms. There is a very good reason for this. The United States is not actually at war with Islam. Non-extremist Muslims account for the lion's share of the victims of jihadist terror, and are needed as allies in the conflict. Air strikes and counterterrorism may be important tools against ISIS, but in the long run, we need non-radicals to maintain the loyalties of the majority of the Muslim world. If the Muslim world gravitates toward its most extreme elements, the West will find itself in an unwinnable struggle against an enemy that can generate fighters moving invisibly among 1.6 billion people worldwide. The radicals want to persuade the rest of the Muslims that they represent Islam writ large in a clash against Christians and Jews. The West’s strategy is predicated on breaking down this link, making it as hard as possible for them to claim that the West is at war with Islam as a whole.

It actually got worse:
And Rubio has rushed out a new video in which he vaguely demands a “clash of civilizations.” Rubio plays it a bit coy, repeatedly describing the conflict as “them” and “us,” without specifying who is them and who is us. This is a characteristically Rubio-esque evasion that allows the most rabid Islamophobes to read his position as a call for a Crusades-style war between Christianity and Islam, but without tying Rubio explicitly to such a formulation. (He can always insist that he meant “us” to include non-violent Muslims.) The problem, of course, is that the most inflammatory interpretation of Rubio’s words is available not only to Christian culture warriors but also to Islamic culture warriors. Indeed, the entire Republican Party has transformed itself into a propaganda machine working in effect, if not intent, to reinforce ISIS’s message that the Christian and Muslim worlds are locked in violent, unresolvable conflict.
What a great recruiting video for ISIS. No really, if Rubio worked for them, he couldn't have done them a more solid than this. Making this a black-and-white war between religions is perfect for them. ISIS would love a fight where even non-radical Muslims are set against the West. Rubio just did his most solid to make that happen. His inexperience and incapability to do the job of President is on display here.

Monday, November 16, 2015

I'm Proud that Governor Tom Wolf is My Governor, and Greg Abbott is Not.

Earlier today, Texas, Michigan, and Alabama's Republican Governors announced they will not accept Syrian refugees into their states. Jeb Bush and Ted Cruz said we should only accept the Christians. Donald Trump thinks taking any refugees is crazy. Texas Governor Greg Abbott even took time to write a letter to the President asking him to take no refugees into the United States right now, for fear of a Paris style attack. Let me remind you, none of the attackers were refugees at all, and the "passport" on one of their dead bodies was planted there after being purchased in Turkey.

I'm proud to state that my Governor, Pennsylvania's Governor, is taking the opposite position of these shameful men. Governor Tom Wolf says refugees are welcome in Pennsylvania, and he will continue to work with the federal government to take in refugees. He is making the moral, humane decision, one that I am proud to live with into our future.

ISIS wants you to hate the refugees, to blame them for the attacks on Paris, and to subject them to harsh new scrutiny that makes life in the West too difficult for them to bare. ISIS wants a clash of civilizations. Let's not lose sight of reality:
The very same refugees entering Europe are often the very same civilians who face the indiscriminate violence and cruel injustice in lands controlled by the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (though, it should be noted, many in Syria are also threatened by the brutal actions of the Syrian government). Globally, studies have shown that Muslims tend to make up the largest proportion of terror victims, with countries such as Syria and Iraq registering the highest toll.
If Muslim refugees come to Europe and are welcomed, it deeply undercuts the Islamic State's legitimacy. Aaron Zelin, a fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, has helpfully catalogued some of the Islamic State's messages on the refugees pouring into Europe from the Middle East. The messages give the impression of deep discomfort and even jealousy that the Muslim population the Islamic State so covets for its self-proclaimed "caliphate" would rather live in "infidel" Western lands.
“Would You Exchange What Is Better For What Is Less?" is the title of one video message. It sounds more than a little like a note from a jilted ex.

Indeed, we must stand with the refugees, and discredit ISIS. I'm proud of Governor Wolf, my Governor. I'm glad I don't have to call Greg Abbott my Governor. 

We Must Stand with the Refugees, Not Shamefully Abandon Them

Let's be clear- none of the people involved in the terrorist attacks on Paris this past Friday are refugees from Syria. Oh sure, they may be Syrian nationals, or even just Arab, but they were not refugees. They did not come to Europe as one of the hundreds of thousands looking for peace. Even the "passport" found on one of the terrorists' body was actually bought in Turkey according to reports. In other words, they had the passport on themselves as a plant, they were not an actual refugee.

ISIS has a stated goal of breaking down the Western concept of co-existence. They have continually told the refugees that they cannot escape them by going to Europe. They have said that real Muslims cannot live in peace in the Western world, where they will be subject to increased scrutiny and surveillance, especially after ISIS pulls off attacks in those regions. They want a black-and-white, one-on-one fight in mind, where all Muslims will have to support them against all non-Muslims. If they can turn Europe and the U.S. against the refugees and Muslims in general, it helps them achieve their stated goal.

The United States has taken in 750,000 refugees since 9/11, and not one of them has been arrested for domestic terrorism since. Zero. Zip. Nada. These people fleeing Syria are human beings who need our help. They face death, living under awful leadership, or worse. America has always been a friend to people in this situation,  it is who we are. It's in our values.

It is shameful to hear Jeb Bush and Ted Cruz talk about instituting a religious litmus test, to say we should only help Christians. It's even more shameful to hear Donald Trump say we shouldn't take any. This is not who America is. This is not about our safety, our safety is not any more in doubt with refugees than without. This is about our values. These men would shamefully abandon our values. It is disgusting.

Sunday, November 15, 2015

Actually Understanding the Paris Attacks, ISIS, and the Middle East

I posted this on Facebook, and afterwards I felt a little bit bad. For a minute at least:

I see a lot of foreign policy experts all of a sudden, which is kind of depressing. If you don't understand the difference between Iran and ISIS, how the Iraq War helped create ISIS, the Syrian Civil War, or why terrorism is increasingly happening in France, please stand down with your opinion. What happened is terrible and scary, but going into foreign countries like a lunatic cowboy is not a response, it's suicide.

While that sounds cold, it is actually the truth of the matter. The American Conservative response is a mish-mash of nonsense that is vaguely related to the truth. Their position is basically "fight everybody over there," even though not everyone over there is on the same side, has the same objectives, or even like each other. Their response is to both call for a war with Iran, and for a war with ISIS, not knowing that those two sides are not in alignment. It is at very least ignorant, if not downright dangerous to listen to anything these people have to say, especially since so much of the problem in that region stems from their last White House, that of President George W. Bush.

Start by understanding why these things are happening in France. Part of the issue is the cultural tensions that exist in France, particularly between the Judeo-Christian background types and Muslims. If you remember the Charlie Hebdo attacks, they stemmed from a cartoon image of the Prophet Muhammad. Indeed, particularly since the 2008 economic crisis, but really before that, anti-Muslim rhetoric has had a place in the French political conversation. The third leading party in France, the National Front, is essentially a white-nationalist party existing in France. It goes well beyond French cultural issues though, which are really not all that unique in multi-cultural, diverse nations (the same is happening in Britain and Germany, and we have had episodes of this as well). France is also the second-largest member in the U.S. lead coalition that is bombing ISIS in Syria right now, undoubtedly a major factor in ISIS wanting to attack them. Between internal tensions with Islam, the bombing war on ISIS they joined in, and France's generally socially liberal society, it's not hard to see why ISIS is targeting them.

Who is ISIS though, and why do they exist? It's important to understand that they are a Sunni-Muslim extremist group that seeks to create a Caliphate across the world, beginning with territory in Iraq and Syria. They came into existence in 1999, joined al-Qaeda in 2004, separated from al-Qaeda in 2014 and created their Caliphate that same year. Beyond Syria and Iraq, they claim territory across North Africa, the Middle East, and into the Indian-Pakistani peninsula. They hate Iran and the Syrian Government, and by proxy, the Russians and Hezbollah. They hate the Free Syrian Army, because they align with us, as well as France and the United Kingdom, all in addition to hating the United States. They obviously hate Israel as well. They have been able to successfully survive as a terror group mostly because of the Iraq War, and the fact that there is no strong central government in Iraq like there was before the war, as well as the added recruiting benefit of Americans "killing Arabs and Muslims" across the region. They used our presence as propaganda, and used it quite well actually. Their leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, is a billionaire, not unlike al-Qaeda's former leader, Osama Bin Laden.

It's important to note here that they hate Iran, the Syrian Government, and Russia, mostly because they are Shiite Muslims. This is important to note when someone says there is some sort of connection between the rise of ISIS and President Obama's nuclear deal with Iran. Anyone who says this is a complete idiot. In fact, ISIS is the best reason for us to talk to Iran and Russia, or to even consider dealing with Syrian Dictator Assad. It's also important to note that ISIS is probably getting financial support from several allies of the United States who are more concerned with their dislike of Iran, Russia, or Assad (namely the Saudis come to mind here). In other words, there aren't some group of "good guys" to go to and figure out an easy way to handle these guys.

It's also worth noting that in Syria, there are many armies taking part in the war. How many? Well, from Wikipedia-
Main belligerents
 Ba'ath Government
(MOD)
Allied groups
 Opposition
(SRCC)
Other allied groups:

Allied militias:
 ISIL
(SDF)
Allied militias:

CJTF–OIR:
 United States
 Canada
 France[12]
 Australia
 Saudi Arabia
 Qatar
 Jordan
 Bahrain
 United Arab Emirates
 Morocco
 United Kingdom
Commanders and leaders

Strength
National Defense Force: 80,000[33]
Iran: 15,000[34]
Russia: 4,000[35]
Ba'ath Brigades: 7,000[36][37]
al-Abbas brigade: 10,000[38] (8,000 Iraqis)[39]
Hezbollah: 3,000–5,000[40]
Syrian Resistance: 2,000[41]
FSA: 40,000–50,000[42]
Islamic Front: 40,000–70,000[43]
Ajnad al-Sham Union: up to 15,000
AD Front: 13,000[44]
Army of Mujahedeen: 5,000[45]–12,000[46]
Alwiya al-Furqan: 2,000+

  • al-Nusra Front: 13,000[47][48]
  • Ahrar al-Sham: 10-20,000
  • Sham Legion:2,000+[49]
31,500[50]–100,000[51]
People's Protection Units (YPG): 65,000[52]
Jabhat al-Akrad: 7,000[53]
Casualties and losses
 Syrian Government: 52,077–87,077 soldiers killed[54][55]
35,235–49,235 militiamen killed[54][55]
7,000 soldiers and militiamen and 2,000 supporters captured[56]
InfoboxHez.PNG Hezbollah:
971 killed[54]
Other non-Syrian fighters:
3,395 killed[54][c]
80,762–121,762 fighters killed[d]
979 protesters killed[57]
26,500 fighters and supporters captured or missing[54]
 ISIL:
8,143 fighters killed[58]
Rojava Rojava:
1,276–1,445 fighters killed[59]

In other words, the Syrian Civil War is a really complicated conflict. There are some bad guys at the lead of just about each side. By my count, there are about 52 armed groups listed above, ranging from actual countries, to terrorist groups, to groups that are clearly Islamic in nature, but I have no idea what they are. ISIS is a part of that conflict, a part that is opposed for instance by both the U.S. and Russia, but the U.S. and Russia don't agree on who it is they back. It is really much tougher than you may think to solve this conflict.

My point is that when you hear American conservatives say this is reason to enter the Syrian Civil War as a full-fledged combatant, or time to rip up the Iranian nuclear deal and bomb their nuclear power-plants, or that we need to "get tough with Putin," or "go back into Iraq," these are all half-baked, un-thought-out ramblings of the same people who thought it was a good idea to go into Iraq for no reason in 2003. Had we not listened to them then, it's doubtful ISIS would be carrying out multiple attacks in Paris, Beirut, Baghdad, or elsewhere. If we listen to them now, I do not doubt that we could end up stuck in a long-fight that would not end unlike the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan did several decades ago.

One final point, about the refugee crisis, which hard-right-wingers in Europe and America are saying should simply be ended by "sending them all back." While it is possible that one of Paris attackers entered Europe with a Syrian refugee passport, that is not yet confirmed. It is confirmed though that hundreds of thousands of refugees are fleeing the chaos and terrorism that is going on in Syria. Absolutely no one should live under the extremists in ISIS, and it is morally necessary that we help these people escape genocide on all sides in their home country. We absolutely need to screen them and do our best to keep radicals out. We also cannot entertain the position of forcing these people to stay in the closest approximation to hell on this Earth.

When you hear someone say we should get tough, ignore them. When someone tells you it's easy to solve the ISIS issue, ignore them too. Everything about this region is highly complicated, and listening to the likes of Bibi Netanyahu, Marco Rubio, or Jeb Bush  is not going to get you to an intelligent answer. It's just going to make you the latest pseudo-foreign policy expert.