Showing posts with label identity politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label identity politics. Show all posts

Thursday, March 10, 2016

Enough Identity Politics Already

Senator Bernie Sanders stunned just about everyone in politics on Tuesday when he won the Michigan Primary. It was his most significant victory to date in this primary process, and it gives him some desperately needed new life in the 2016 nomination fight. Even so, he trails by about 650 delegates, and Clinton is easily on track to win the nomination in Philadelphia next Summer. It seems fitting though to let Sanders have his moment of victory, after a hard-fought win.

Of course, that doesn't happen in politics, and the "hot takes" are coming out of everywhere. The easiest way to let me know that you don't know much about demographic politics is for you to refer to the "Latino vote" as though it is a monolithic block of voters- as though Cuban-Americans in Florida and Mexican-Americans in Texas have a lot in common besides (perhaps) language. Those groups certainly don't vote overly similar in Presidential races. The second easiest way is to refer to the "white male vote," as though that is a thing. There is very little resemblance in the politics of white men in Alabama and Tennessee and white men in Michigan or Massachusetts, both of whom are also quite different in their political interests. That is evident in their Presidential voting as well. No Democratic nominee is going to break 30% with white guys in the South. If they do that poorly in Michigan and Ohio though, they lost the election (note here: We've lost one of the last five popular votes for President, so obviously we're doing better with white men in the "Rust Belt"). So of course, I completely reject this logic:
As surprising as this result was, however, the exit polling fit right into the pattern that we’ve been seeing from other Democratic primaries. CNN shows that women and people of color support Clinton. Sanders eked out his win in Michigan on the backs of white male supporters, his most robust group of supporters across the country.

This isn’t unusual, either. Clinton is sweeping with people of color everywhere. And while Sanders has won with women in a couple of states — New Hampshire,Vermont — exit poll data shows that in most states where Sanders won, he didn’t win the majority of women.

Maybe getting white men while losing everyone else is enough. There’s no doubt that Tuesday’s results made the delegate race a little tighter and likely invigorated the Sanders campaign to keep on pushing. It’s not inconceivable that a few more wins like this could turn the tide for Sanders.

But if so, nominating a candidate whose base looks a lot more like the Republicans than the Democrats is a problem. The grim reality is that, in a general election, white men will vote for the Republican. Nominating a candidate whose strongest base of support comes from the same demographic that will never vote for a Democrat should give us all pause. It goes against all the lessons we learned from Barack Obama about coalition building and how Democrats win because of their diverse voting base.
Again, let's be clear here- Democrats will lose the white-male vote overall nationally, and most certainly in the South. No one disputes that. There are Democratic states where white men will not be any part of the winning coalition, because they vote Republican (Most of Virginia and North Carolina fit this mold, for instance). There are also states where white guys are, and have to be, part of the coalition. Swing-states across I-80 from Pennsylvania to Iowa require a competitive, if minority share of the white-man vote. These men are mostly moved by economics- which is why they have been pegged as "Reagan Democrats" at times, for their penchant for liking tax-cutters. Sanders making a case that he can win these men over with issues such as international trade and universal health care is a legitimate case that he is electable. Obviously, he needs more than that. In Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania, he needs to show he can turn out African-Americans in numbers that rival President Obama or even Bill Clinton. In the rest of the country he needs to show he can do more than just win white men, as that's not a pathway to victory in Virginia, or in Florida, or in Nevada, for instance. It's also not something we should dismiss as meaningless- a lot of white men in Michigan have to vote for our nominee for the nominee to win the state, and the White House.

I've worked for a lot of diverse candidates. I worked for the first African-American woman to be elected to Congress in the history of New Jersey, the only Bosnian-American and Muslim woman in the Iowa House, Jewish candidates, African-American candidates, and of course, Hillary Clinton in the past. I believe in diversity. I don't believe in "forced" diversity through identity politics. I also don't know that I see any evidence that it really works politically. The most important thing we can do as progressives is win the 2016 election. Given the opposition, I don't think losing is an option. There is a theory out there, that if we nominate a white man, we will lose because of a lack of enthusiasm from our base. While I don't support Bernie Sanders, I don't buy into this theory. I don't necessarily buy that we are going to get Obama-esque turnout from our base from either candidate, but I don't think Bernie is necessarily in worse shape than Hillary there. I'm also not sure that his pathway to winning Michigan in the general is less legitimate than her's, just because he's relying on a group of voters we've been relying on to win every time since 1988. In short, I think this whole argument is outside of reality, and rests too much on theory. Sometimes we can overthink our identity politics leanings, particularly when we're unhappy with the results we get.

Friday, December 4, 2015

The Driving Force of the Next Couple of Decades in American Political Life

American history can be split up into different periods, where different factors were the driving force behind our political divide. Obviously we've had regional divisions (Civil War period), ideological differences (federalists vs. states rights in the beginning), and economic (the period from FDR's election up through at least the Kennedy assassination). From 1968 up through about 2008, our country was largely divided along cultural lines. Culture took on multiple forms, sometimes governmental (the small government movement), sometimes racial (busing segregation fight), sometimes militant (the Iraq War), and sometimes truly cultural (parental warning notices on rap CDs in the early 1990s). We've fought about things like law and order, taxation, the social safety net, religion in the public sphere, the sexual revolution, women's rights, abortion, guns, and marriage equality. The divide has been between conservative and liberal views of the way we live, and that has been the driving factor in our politics- not economics and facing down Communism, as was the case in the FDR-Truman-Eisenhower-Kennedy-and even to some extent, Johnson eras.

I think we all knew that 2008 was a significant election, a game-changing election even, but we couldn't put our finger on how things had changed after that race. It's becoming clear to me. We haven't really "exited" the culture war period in America, per se, but it's morphed into something much bigger and more passionate. In the post-2008 world, we are in an "identity" based political struggle. On the right, they want to define the nation much like a European nation, like a France or Germany, in that they want a religion, a pre-dominant race, a most common religion that guides affairs, strong borders, strong businesses, and a strong military presence to project the strength of "the people." On the left, they want a multi-cultural nation that embraces diversity, different cultures, different views on religion, welcomes new and different people, focuses on the social justice that is needed for traditional minorities, and is less militant and homogeneous. We are seeing this play out in most of our major political disputes right now.

Right-wing America sees America as Christian, English speaking, defined within our borders, exceptional in the world, wealthy, and by and large, culturally white. They believe in a militarized, defined border. They are not fans of immigration, by and large. They think we don't need to have signs in Spanish, everyone should speak English. They think people should go to church on Sundays, and should embrace Christian values. They believe in very traditionalistic family structures. They think if something is a threat, be it ISIS, Iran, Russia, China, or whoever, we should fight them with our might. They believe the police are generally right, and Black Lives Matter should stop criticizing "the good guys." They think that most of the poor simply lost in the market economy, and should have worked harder. They think they're an individual, and should live in an individual world. They don't want to "help the other." They feel it's fine to be empowered by their gun, to defend their property and being.

Left-wing America sees America as the "melting-pot." They see us as a nation of immigrants. They see the Civil Rights Movement as never ending, at least not until all people achieve social justice. If there are some having their rights denied by formal or informal bigotry, they want to take that on. They embrace foreign cultures, other languages, and other religions. They embrace a poly-theist, and even anti-theist nation, where not everyone practices religion the same way. They believe in protest movements, and bringing their cause to the forefront of American debate, even when the public doesn't really want them to. They believe in collective action, and economic fairness and equality. They believe women should have all the rights that men do, and even some believe that the "female perspective" on the world is a better one in some or all cases than men. Gender and sexuality equality is important to the left.

Basically, one embraces a very defined society, the other a very open one. This dispute is not one with "shared goals," or even many shared values. The values are actually at the core of the dispute. For the millions of Americans who share some of both, and are in the middle of this, the entire dispute is a huge turn off, but the passions on both polar ends will still rule the political day. This is an identity fight, a fight over who the country really is. Is it a "melting pot" of diversity, of different cultures and ways, and fairness for all it's groups of people? Or is it "'Murrica," a Christian, English speaking, pure Capitalist, "strong" nation?

The next couple of decades are going to be very difficult for people who don't embrace identity politics and the divisions that define our nation and our politics. The idea of compromise and working together towards shared goals is nothing more than a talking point now. There isn't much agreement between the two sides on what to even work on, let alone what the outcome should be. Cold War America was about working to the most successful outcome for the good of the nation, and the disagreement was about the pathway there. This is a dispute over what America really is. I fear that the ugly rhetoric of a Donald Trump, the rise of polarizing political figures, and fighting over the basic rights that people had come to take for granted, is the new norm. I fear we'll fight more about birth-right citizenship and contraception in the decades to come. I think we're entering something ugly, and that ugly thing will last a long time. I think the election of Barack Obama, and his embrace of a more progressive, open policy agenda has awakened a backlash that will come to define American politics for a long time. It's somewhat generational, somewhat racial and religious, and somewhat fear driven. It's a struggle that is likely to leave us as divided as ever.